Free Consultation
Request a Free Consultation

Should I Accept the Insurance Company’s First Offer?

Injured in a car accident in Illinois? Don’t rush to accept the first insurance offer—get the compensation you deserve.

Suppose you’ve recently been involved in a car accident in Illinois, especially in Peoria, Tazewell County, or the surrounding communities. In that case, the insurance company may offer a settlement. While it may be tempting to accept—especially if you’re facing mounting medical bills or missed work—it’s crucial to understand what’s at stake.

Don’t settle for less. Find out how much your case is worth before signing away your rights. Contact Schierer & Ritchie LLC Today.

lady-justice
Hey, thank you again for the consultation… you’re amazing!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for the kind words. Good luck with everything!!
Had amazing communication. Gave me the right resources to find what I was looking for. Contacted me within a short amount of time regarding my situation.
I want to appreciate all the work Mr. Schierer and his staff has gone through with my case. I'm very thankful for even the recommendation to Mr.Schierer this was a really great opportunity I thank you guys so much!
Response from the owner:Thank you for the kind words. We very much appreciate it. Happy to have the opportunity to work with you.
Helped me and my family, number one lawyer I recommend to everyone took care of us and has a great staff
Best law firm in the city!! My boy schierer got me my money and my case over faster than a New York minute!! U forsure got an invite to my wedding!!🫡🦾
Response from the owner:Christopher, thank you so much. It was an honor to help you.
Mr. Schierer and his team made my experience a breeze and did an excellent job in negotiating my plea! 10/10 would recommend them!
Response, quick and cost-effective. Would recommend them highly.
Super friendly supportive staff who were very patient with all questions, Cannot say how helpful and Informative everyone was. I definitely recommend this place.
Great experience explained our case in detail. Highly recomended
I called them in January for a claim and 8 months of them working hard I received a check highly recommended

Why Insurance Companies Offer Quick Settlements

Insurance adjusters are trained negotiators; their job is to save their company money, not to ensure you are fairly compensated. That “generous” first offer may seem helpful, but it is often far less than what your case is worth.

Their Goal: Settle Fast, Pay Less

  • Minimize payout: They know you may be overwhelmed and vulnerable.
  • Avoid full liability: Once you accept and sign, you waive your right to future claims—even if new injuries or costs emerge.
  • Pressure tactics: They may create urgency or imply that it’s a limited-time offer.

The Hidden Costs After a Car Accident

The true value of your claim includes more than just your initial medical bills and car repairs.

Here’s what you might miss out on if you accept the first offer:

In many cases, victims don’t realize the extent of their injuries until weeks or even months later—after they’ve already accepted a lowball settlement.

Common Insurance Company Tactics in Illinois

  • “This is the best we can do.”
  • “You don’t need a lawyer.”
  • “We can’t pay for anything else once you sign.”

These tactics are designed to limit your options—not protect your rights.

Never Sign Anything Without Talking to an Attorney

If you’re wondering whether to accept the first offer, ask yourself:

  • Do I know the full extent of my injuries?
  • Have I seen a specialist or had follow-up care?
  • Do I know what my case is worth?

If you answered “no” to any of these, it’s time to speak with an experienced car accident attorney.

What to Do Instead

Here’s what we recommend for accident victims in Peoria, East Peoria, Washington, Morton, and all of Tazewell County:

  • Politely decline to sign or accept anything until you’ve spoken to a lawyer.
  • Document everything: injuries, bills, lost wages, etc.
  • Call us for a free consultation. We’ll review your case and give you an honest assessment—without pressure or cost.

Why Schierer & Ritchie, LLC?

Unlike corporate law firms that shuffle you off to a junior paralegal, when you call us, you’ll speak directly with a seasoned attorney who knows how to negotiate aggressively with insurance companies and how to win in Illinois courts.

We don’t take the easy way out. We take your side.

banner

Get Real Help. Real Results.

Don’t settle for less. Find out how much your case is worth before signing away your rights.
Contact Schierer & Ritchie LLC Today.

Schierer & Ritchie, LLC
4.9
Based on 116 reviews